Friday, 6 March 2015
Bangkok: The Barkyard
Wednesday, 25 February 2015
Anniversary of MH370
I like the way this documentary sifts the information garnered so far. It goes through each theory that has been considered and presented it logically, disproves which that does not fit.
“Duncan
2014/04/05 at 22:15
2014/04/05 at 22:15
My information is (as noted in other comments from me) that the UK AAIB has refused to make the ping data to others. I do not mean ‘the public’. Specifically, I have been told that the UK AAIB has refused to make the ping data available to the relevant French authority (the BEA: Bureau d’Enquêtes et d’Analyses pour la sécurité de l’aviation civile) despite the French transport ministry making a direct request. The BEA – which I am again told was invited to be involved in the overall investigation by the Malaysian Government due to the fact that it was the BEA that was investigating the last event even vaguely like this, the Air France crash into the Atlantic a few years ago – apparently sent a team to KL but after waiting for ten days for the ping data they gave up and went home to Paris. Of course, the information I have been given by someone who wishes to remain anonymous might be wrong, but s/he is an experienced airline captain with close contacts to the BEA.
The above might mean that the JACC does not have the ping data; or perhaps the British would give the data to Australia and not to France?
Whichever, I’d suggest to readers that they might prompt some decent investigative journalists to follow that lead and shake it until it hurts. Not your local media. I am talking about the NY Times, the Washington Post, Le Monde, Der Spiegel, The Times, The Daily Telegraph (London), The Guardian.
Cheers and best of luck,
Duncan”
http://www.duncansteel.com/archives/549/comment-page-1#comment-903Thursday, 12 February 2015
Malaysian famous singer : Kamahl
Kamahl - our Singing Star Down Under
by Loh Kok Kin
Sometime in 1987, a crew from the WWF (not that "sports entertainment" organisation, but its environmental namesake) visited Pasar Road School, where I was studying. Gathered in the school hall, we were acquainted with the threats confronting the leatherback turtles of Rantau Abang, the Indian elephants and Sumatran tigers. But tugging our heartstrings were not the droning lectures, nor the still photographs of the exhibition; it was the deep, creamy voice crooning the words of ‘The Elephant Song’ while moving images of those endangered species flashed across the screen via cine-reel. This was the first time I had heard, and heard of, Kamahl.
amahl has sold more records internationally than any Malaysian artist (P. Ramlee included). He has made or released recordings in 21 countries in every continent. He has sung for Queen Elizabeth and other royalty, counts media moghuls like Rupert Murdoch as friends, kept (and still keeps) correspondence with sporting greats such as world cricket legend Donald Bradman, and has won enough coveted music awards to fill a trophy cabinet many times over. Kamahl was also deemed the undisputed successor to the illustrious Frank Sinatra for a song that is now a signature work of Kamahl’s. Yet few Victorians are aware that they share a common V.I. heritage with this international celebrity.
At 11.30 a.m. on Tuesday, 13 November 1934, a second child and first son was born to Kandiah Mayilvaganam (a chief clerk in the engineering department of Malayan Railways) and Elyathangam. They named him ‘Kamaleswaran’, now more fondly known as Kamahl (Kamahl subsequently changed his name to Kamalesvaren to save explaining that ‘w’ was non-existent in Ceylonese and that
![]()
The area around the General Hospital and Sentul was his happy hunting ground as a child. But it could have been his graveyard too. Towards the end of World War Two, the Allies were raining bombs across different towns in Malaya and Kuala Lumpur, the capital, certainly did not escape. One day, Kamahl’s mother ordered him on an errand in Sentul. However, he strolled away from his destination, setting himself for a walloping from his mother. Fortunately, when he returned home, his mother not only spared him, but was glad he had wandered. For minutes after he strayed from the destination, the Allies had bombed the Sentul railway yards. Had Kamahl obeyed his mother, he would have walked straight into the air raid.
![]()
At the V.I., where Kamahl studied from 1946 to 1952, this Loke Yew House boy (in his official biography, he is incorrectly recorded as a Shaw House boy) defied his parents’ expectations and applied his enthusiasm to hockey and soccer for his house, and played cricket for the school. Once, his sporting enthusiasm almost nipped his future singing career in the bud. In one cricket game, he mis-timed a full toss and the ball smashed into his mouth, ramming his teeth in and damaging his gums. Worse, Kamahl’s treatment was delayed because he diverted to the post office on his way home, and when he got home his mother, thinking he had been in a fight, gave him a beating, instead of taking him to the clinic. He never played cricket again until he went to Australia.
So he switched sports. His team-mate for this new sport was none other than Mohd Hashim Ali, later General Tan Sri, the Chief of the Malaysian Defence Forces and in 1998, Chief Executive Officer of the Commonwealth Games. Interviewed in 2001, Tan Sri Hashim remembered Kamahl fondly: "He’s very suave and polite. We had many a happy memory playing padder tennis." Padder tennis was played on a badminton court, using wooden bats (similar to, but sturdier than, table-tennis bats) to strike a tennis ball. Interest in the game petered off because the V.I. boys were keener on adrenaline-sapping sports like football, hockey and proper tennis. Kamahl captained the Loke Yew House padder tennis team as well as soccer team.
Even in his early years, Kamahl stamped his singular mark on all he did. His parents had wanted him to study but he had preferred sports. Padder tennis was new and so he blazed a trail for it. In April 1952 the VIOBA announced it was organising a two-day Grand Carnival and Trade Fair in the school premises to raise funds for its clubhouse and it needed attractive posters to lure the K.L public. Noticing that few Indian boys ever succeeded in art, Kamahl decided to enter the design competition for the posters. Astounding everyone else, two of his designs clinched second place. In the 1952 photo of the V.I.’s graduating class, Kamahl dons a black suit, marking him out prominently amidst the sea of traditional white-suited classmates and teachers. Yet, he was no nasty rebel. In Kamahl’s leaving testimonial, the headmaster, Mr J.N. Davies (an Englishman from Birmingham) wrote: "A most conscientious, pleasant and reliable personality. Well-balanced."
![]()
Kamahl never forgot the V.I. In 1994, he visited the V.I. museum, while I was on duty. He stopped at one stall, gazed on the words of the school song and said "These aren’t the words that we used to sing". Only later that night did the familiar profile of that visitor register in my memory, and I kicked myself for not asking for his autograph. And many years later, I realised I missed an even bigger opportunity. His comment must have referred to ‘The Old Gray School’, a short-lived School Song that was taught to a handful of classes in the late 1940’s, before the present G.F. Jackson version was composed. I should have requested his rendition of it.
In 1953, complying with his parents' wish that their eldest son pursued a higher education, he decided to do his matriculation in Australia. The cargo ship he boarded to Adelaide carried a load of cattle as well. Officially, Australia was still in the throes of Arthur Calwell’s "Two Wongs don’t make a White" ideology, which treated non-Europeans as second-class residents. Under rime Minister Robert Menzies, it was staunchly Anglo-Saxon in its outlook. People could not understand why Kamahl would be horrified at cows being slaughtered with spikes jammed into their bovine skulls. They would stare when he and his friends went into the town on weekends to do their shopping. Schoolmates called him Camel. He was embarrassed by his meagre English. Kamahl did his best to be accepted. During one lesson where he was asked to describe his travel experience from Kuala Lumpur, he said he found the air hostesses ‘very serviceable’. When his classmates rolled about in laughter he repeated himself, not seeing the joke in it.
![]()
He played hockey and got to represent the combined universities’ team against the New Zealand hockey squad, where his team lost 1-0. It was his first and only international as a sportsman. Kamahl returned to cricket. The master at King’s College, where he matriculated, noted him for "very accurate off-breaks…useful hard-hitting left-hander…needs to use his feet more…a keen fieldsman." But all these endeavours merely masked his misery; and masked them well, for Kamahl was a good actor. When he was alone and needed cheering up, he turned to his heritage – he would sing classical Indian (Carnatic) music to himself.
While Kamahl was in the V.I., his father had schooled him in the complexities of the Hindu music trinity, Mummorthi Vizha, the Navarathri festival, Thamizhosai Vizha and Thevara chanting. At the very least, the family had hoped Kamahl could make a living by teaching these arts at the Sangeetha Abivirthi Sabha, a school of Indian fine arts. This legacy of Carnatic music was to be his companion for life. So powerful was its influence that Kamahl never understood how people could like Western music, which seemed so hollow and mindless. But this was before he heard Nature Boy by Nat King Cole, the fast rising crooner, and later, Ol’ Man River by Paul Robeson.
As a student in Adelaide, Kamahl and his friends regularly visited the Morecombe household during the weekends. For overseas students, such families like the Morecombes provided a home away from home, with home cooked meals and a chance to mingle with fellow Asians thrown in. Besides word games, these gatherings were song-filled. Unlike his friends, Kamahl was too shy to sing or do any
impersonations. But these sessions got him listening to the radio, and it was then that he first heard Nat King Cole's silken tones wafting over the air waves. Even so, his admiration for Nat’s voice would have been for naught but for his longing for attention, that which his compatriots who performed during the weekly gatherings seemed to get so much of. So Kamahl secretly practised in his shower until he felt he was ready for his debut!
That big evening, he pulled Mrs Morecombe aside and told her to dim the room lights first, in the ridiculous hope that he wouldn’t be recognised if he made an idiot of himself. He needn't have worried. "I got a wonderful reaction," Kamahl remembers. "I sang without accompaniment – a capella. It’s the way I sang from then on. Always without music, no regard for metre. I just stopped and started when I wanted to. Any thought of metre or rhyme was unimportant. Forget about harmony. I didn’t know what it was." From that day onwards, he kept singing. And singing. Whenever he went to coffee bars with his friends, Kamahl would get them to persuade the proprietor to ask him to sing. But still he was not envisaging a singing career. He took the positive reception to his singing as merely a sign of his acceptance to that foreign land.
Yet Australia, though it had relaxed its residency requirements for non-Europeans, still had its White Australia policy. Education was the sole reason that Kamahl had been given a temporary visa. He went to university to study architecture, a decision partly motivated by his success in the VIOBA poster design competition. When he performed dismally, he switched to arts where, according to his friend Barry Moeller, "he took every course except street sweeping." Even then, his results gave him little solace and his continued stay in Australia seemed doomed as repatriation loomed. The university registrar gave Kamahl one final opportunity. He fixed an appointment for him to see the director of the Elder Conservatorium of Music and, within days, Kamahl was safely enrolled in the Conservatorium.
Convinced that Kamahl’s singing had dimmed his prospects of ever completing university, the Department of Immigration intensified its scrutiny of this wandering minstrel. Immigration rarely gave second chances, but Kamahl, despite having failed architecture and arts, won his reprieve from the Department. But eventually, when that expired in 1958,
the order came from Canberra: Bill Schneider, the immigration officer in Adelaide, was to deport Kamahl. Bill, who had been impressed by Kamahl’s performances on Australia’s Amateur Hour, did his best to stall the order, offering excuses including one that Kamahl was one of Australia’s most promising musicians. It didn’t wash; Canberra was insistent.
Bill did the unthinkable; he lied to Canberra that the wandering minstrel had wandered from his sight. It was a half-lie. Kamahl had, indeed, wandered off, but Bill knew he had gone to Sydney. Indeed, Bill was one of the many white knights in Kamahl’s moments of despair, and many such moments had he. In 1962, Kamahl travelled to the Gold Coast, tempted by the promise of an acquaintance that an eight-week contract awaited him at a local coffee bar. But there was no contract, nor had they heard of him and his acquaintance was nowhere to be found. Penniless, Kamahl ventured into the Zuider Zee restaurant, and asked to sing for his meals. Not only was he fed for the day, he was also well-liked by his audience. In the audience was Stirling Moss, the famous British racing driver who recommended Kamahl to a local hotel, where he performed for the next six weeks. A stint on Brisbane television soon followed.
However, the publicity attracted problems. After Kamahl moved to Sydney in 1963, where he first performed at the hang-out of celebrities, the Hotel Australia, his fame finally led Immigration to him. Deportation loomed for Kamahl. Again, Lady Luck kicked in. Among his fans at the Hotel Australia was an old friend he had first met in Adelaide, and with whom he was now lodging. This friend now became Kamahl’s guarantor, writing to Immigration once or twice a year to assure them of Kamahl’s continuing ‘serious’ music studies. This old friend was none other than Rupert Murdoch, who had taken over his family’s newspaper business in Adelaide before penetrating the lucrative Sydney media market in the late 1950’s. (Today, the Murdoch worldwide empire includes Foxtel, News Corporation and BSkyB, among others.)
![]()
Kamahl was granted Australian citizenship in 1967. I remember how proud I was when, in 1998, I read in the newspapers the proclamation that Kamahl was ‘Father Of The Year’, a title that in the previous year had gone to John Howard, the Prime Minister. A Malaysian-born, what more an Old Boy of the V.I., declared as an exemplary citizen of Australia, what a feat! And if anyone were to condemn him as a musician past his used-by date, I need only cite his recent invitation to perform at the Big Day Out 2004, the largest youth rock festival in Australia. Kamahl still stirs passion.
Still, it was an uphill task before others saw him for what he was. Even as a young performer, Kamahl had resented being hailed as the ‘Asian Paul Robeson’, or being labelled as a Nat King Cole or a Harry Belafonte. "I don’t say I’m not accepted here, but I feel that if I wasn’t coloured, I wouldn’t be compared to Robeson and other coloured artists." It seemed that those listening to him were merely fantasising about someone else. Kamahl wanted to stamp his mark as an individual and chart his own course in life. Throughout the early sixties, Kamahl played hide and seek with Australian Immigration. Then, in 1966, after an incident at a Brisbane pub, he was asked to report immediately to the authorities in Sydney. He thought that this was it. First, a lady at Immigration read the riot act to him and then she said, 'We've been asked to give you permanent resident status'.
Hours after being granted permanent residency, Kamahl went to the nearest phone box and called St Vincent's hospital where a Fijian Indian lass - Saodra Tikaram - was working. 'Would you like to get married?', he asked. She said, 'When?' He said, 'This week'. He was in love with her but she had been promised to someone else in Fiji. Her mother wasn't very pleased but the rest of the family went along. When Kamahl wrote to his uncle that he had made singing his career and had defied his family’s wishes for an arranged marriage and had, instead, wed a Fijian Indian two rungs below them, his uncle never contacted him for three years. Today Kamahl and Saodra have been married 37 years and have two children, Rajan and Rani. The latter has followed the footsteps of her illustrious father in becoming a performing artist.
Certainly, Kamahl had failures. His first album was recorded by Philips in 1967. Nervous about this raw, untested singer, the manager of Philips records
settled on a church in Sydney’s inner-west as the recording venue. As Kamahl recalls, "If you listen hard, you can hear the traffic outside." This album, A Voice To Remember, sold barely more than 1000 copies. Eager to propel sales, Kamahl called the promotions department of David Jones, a leading retail store in Sydney, and volunteered to promote the album himself. They invited him on a Saturday morning, but his day passed with little activity. Finally, a customer approached him and he prepared to autograph his first album. Instead, she asked if he had Elvis Presley’s latest release. She had mistaken Kamahl for a shop assistant!
Somehow, Kamahl convinced Philips to produce another album for him. They called it Dreams Of Love. But they refused to include the little-known song Sounds Of Goodbye. Now Kamahl dealt his terms; he argued that since the studio time for Dreams Of Love was going to take, say, twenty hours, if they finished with two hours left, with enough spare time could they do Sounds Of Goodbye as a single? He got his wish but when the single went out, nothing happened until the Australian Broadcasting Corporation broadcast the song in Melbourne and talked about this fellow called ‘Kamahl’. Soon commercial stations picked up the story and the resulting publicity made Dreams Of Love Kamahl’s first gold hit in 1969.
During the course of my research, I discovered I wasn't the first present boy to have made contact with Kamahl after he had become a singing icon. In 1982, the V.I.O.B.A. invited Kamahl to perform at the association's Diamond Jubilee celebrations but the singing sensation had a prior booking elsewhere and so had to turn down the invitation with apologies. Nonetheless, he penned a warm message to The Victorian of that year with a message that “I have very fond memories of my boyhood days at the school and these memories are kept alive by the many friendships that have developed since those days. It is my unshakeable belief that it is friends who make life worthwhile.” Accompanying the letter was a poem he had penned, entitled Friends. (It is reproduced at the end of this article).
Kamahl has since performed for royalty such as Queen Juliana of Denmark and Queen Elizabeth II at the Royal Command Performance in 1976 and 1982, respectively. In the 1990s, he even flew back to Malaysia for a private performance for Malay royalty. Kamahl has performed at the Sydney Opera House and the glamorous Carnegie Hall. He won the Sydney Daily Telegraph readers’ poll for Variety’s Mo awards four years in a row, and, in 1994, he became "Kamalesvaren Kandiah AM", a Member of the Order Of Australia, the country's third highest titular class. But behind all the glitter and gold, Kamahl has contributed generously towards the Save The Children Fund (which brought him into contact with Princess Ann), the UNICEF Benefit Concert and the World Wildlife Fund.
![]()
In 1975, the Dutch composer Hans van Hemert composed a song for the musical finale of a TV special on the World Wildlife Fund. Frank Sinatra was approached to sing it but turned it down. Van Hemert asked the vice-president of Polygram to send him records of singers who "must have the grandeur to star in a royal gala" and deemed fit to step into Sinatra’s shoes. When van Hemert heard Kamahl’s voice, he knew he had found the right person. And since then Kamahl has been the voice of The Elephant Song, one of the anthems of the World Wildlife Fund.
It was a fitting tribute when in 2003, Kamahl released Imagine The World In Unison, an album marking his fiftieth anniversary in Australia, and The Elephant Song was included in the list of hits. After all, Kamahl has been a giant in his own right, bestriding the music scene for nearly half a century. People all over the world love the uniquely sonorous, bellowing voice of this former V.I. boy who once played cricket, football, hockey and padder tennis. A boy who sought love and attention and dreamed dreams. The words of his very first Western song, Nature Boy have indeed come full circle:
The greatest thing you’ll ever learn
Is just to love and be loved in return.
Happy 70th Birthday, Kamahl!
![]()
This article draws heavily on Christopher Day’s Kamahl – An Impossible Dream
|
Friends are never earned
They’re a gift from the loving God And they are precious beyond human valuation But you dare not take them for granted Or they will drift away like smoke And the warmth of their caring will vanish Like the chill of the endless nights. Most of my friends are unknowns And they probably won’t rate an obituary Unless they live and die in small towns Where nothing much ever happens. But a few of my friends are big people And they have made the world ring With laughter and music They are famous, sensitive, talented And their names are household words Yet they are no more precious in God’s eyes Or in mine Than those wonderful nobodies Who live and die in small towns. |
Who is your friend?
He is someone who warms you with a nod Or with the unspoken word in hard times When you’re hurting beyond words Who is your friend? She is someone who holds you against her breast And sighs softly into your hair When no other medicine can stop the pain. A friend is someone who clinks his glass against yours Or answers the phone at three in the morning When you’re lost And, with a few words of encouragement and concern, Makes you realize you aren’t really lost at all. Friends come in both sexes and in all shapes and sizes But the most important thing they have in common Is the ability to share with you Your most sky-splitting joys or Your deepest most awesome sorrows For they are your friends. |
Created on October 31, 2004.
Last update October 31, 2004.
Page-Keeper: Chung Chee Min
|
Friday, 9 January 2015
CH controversial covers explained
CH Most controversial covers explained
Charlie Hebdo’s Most Controversial Religious Covers, Explained
By Miriam Krule

Photo illustration by Slate.
On Wednesday, masked gunmen attacked the offices of the French satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo killing at least 12 people. While both the motive and the identity of the perpetrators are still unknown, the magazine is famous for its controversial cartoon covers. (Today’s cover features novelist Michel Houellebecq smoking a cigarette with the caption “In 2022, I will do Ramadan.” His latest novel, Submission, is said to be about a future France run by Muslims.) While they’ve mocked everything from Sept. 11 to Michael Jackson, Charlie Hebdo has riled up the most controversy when covering religion, particularly the Prophet Mohammed—who many Muslims believe it is forbidden to depict.

In 2006, the magazine featured Mohammed weeping with the headline “Mohammed Overwhelmed by Fundamentalism.” This was the cover of the issue that also featured reprinted cartoons from the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten that caricatured the prophet. Jacques Chirac, French president at the time, denounced the magazine and Muslim groups sued, but courts eventually ruled in Charlie Hebdo’s favor.

Perhaps the issue of the magazine that inspired the largest international reaction was published in 2012, and sports a cover depicting an orthodox Jewish man pushing a Muslim man in a wheelchair. The headline reads “Intouchables 2,” a spoof of the movie The Intouchables—at the time, France’s second biggest box-office hit—in which a rich white man who is paralyzed from the neck down hires a black ex-con from the projects to be his caretaker. But, as with the 2006 cover, the deeper controversy came on the next page with a satire of another movie, this time Innocence of Muslims, in which an ex-con paid people to act out scenes that had nothing to do with Islam before replacing the audio to create a terrible movie ridiculing the Prophet Mohammed. No one saw the movie at the time, but he posted a 14-minute video on YouTube and an anti-Muslim activist in Virginia translated it into Arabic and sent the link to activists in Egypt resulting in violent protests. The Charlie Hebdo cartoon depicts the prophet naked and in pornographic poses, and the French government urged the magazine not to publish the images. When the magazine refused, the French government closed embassies and consulates in about 20 countries as a precaution. (The movie and the cartoons also became the center of renewed conversations about free speech.)

The previous year, Mohammed graced the cover to celebrate the Tunisian Islamist party Ennahda’s victory in the recent elections. As a response, Charlie Hebdo printed a special issue called Charia Hebdo (pronounced like Sharia law, or Islamic law) “guest edited” by the prophet himself. The cover promised “100 lashes if you don’t die of laughter!” Charlie Hebdo’s homepage was subsequently hacked and replaced with the single phrase “No god but Allah.” The office was attacked with a Molotov cocktail that destroyed all the property and equipment inside. (Following that, the magazine published a Muslim man kissing a cartoonist.)

Not all the controversies have centered around depictions of men. In 2010, Charlie Hebdo supported France’s controversial law banning women from wearing burqas in public with the headline “Yes to wearing the burqa … on the inside!”—the intended meaning of which is pretty self-explanatory from the image.

The paper has also mocked the pope on multiple occasions, but perhaps most famous is the 2010 image of Pope Benedict XVI holding a condom above his head saying “This is my body” (a line from the liturgy of the Eucharist that, according to the New Testament, was uttered by Jesus at the Last Supper). This was in response to an excerpt from the book-length interview Light of the World in which the pope says some confusing things about when it is OK to wear a condom. Many considered it to be a reversal for the church to allow condom use to prevent the spread of HIV. The pope said contraception can be “a first step in a movement toward a different way, a more human way, of living sexuality.”
Read more of Slate’s coverage of the Charlie Hebdo attack.
Miriam Krule is a Slate assistant editor. She writes about religion and culture and edits the photography blog Behold.
Charlie Hebdo’s Most Controversial Religious Covers, Explained
By Miriam Krule
Photo illustration by Slate.
On Wednesday, masked gunmen attacked the offices of the French satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo killing at least 12 people. While both the motive and the identity of the perpetrators are still unknown, the magazine is famous for its controversial cartoon covers. (Today’s cover features novelist Michel Houellebecq smoking a cigarette with the caption “In 2022, I will do Ramadan.” His latest novel, Submission, is said to be about a future France run by Muslims.) While they’ve mocked everything from Sept. 11 to Michael Jackson, Charlie Hebdo has riled up the most controversy when covering religion, particularly the Prophet Mohammed—who many Muslims believe it is forbidden to depict.
In 2006, the magazine featured Mohammed weeping with the headline “Mohammed Overwhelmed by Fundamentalism.” This was the cover of the issue that also featured reprinted cartoons from the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten that caricatured the prophet. Jacques Chirac, French president at the time, denounced the magazine and Muslim groups sued, but courts eventually ruled in Charlie Hebdo’s favor.
Perhaps the issue of the magazine that inspired the largest international reaction was published in 2012, and sports a cover depicting an orthodox Jewish man pushing a Muslim man in a wheelchair. The headline reads “Intouchables 2,” a spoof of the movie The Intouchables—at the time, France’s second biggest box-office hit—in which a rich white man who is paralyzed from the neck down hires a black ex-con from the projects to be his caretaker. But, as with the 2006 cover, the deeper controversy came on the next page with a satire of another movie, this time Innocence of Muslims, in which an ex-con paid people to act out scenes that had nothing to do with Islam before replacing the audio to create a terrible movie ridiculing the Prophet Mohammed. No one saw the movie at the time, but he posted a 14-minute video on YouTube and an anti-Muslim activist in Virginia translated it into Arabic and sent the link to activists in Egypt resulting in violent protests. The Charlie Hebdo cartoon depicts the prophet naked and in pornographic poses, and the French government urged the magazine not to publish the images. When the magazine refused, the French government closed embassies and consulates in about 20 countries as a precaution. (The movie and the cartoons also became the center of renewed conversations about free speech.)
The previous year, Mohammed graced the cover to celebrate the Tunisian Islamist party Ennahda’s victory in the recent elections. As a response, Charlie Hebdo printed a special issue called Charia Hebdo (pronounced like Sharia law, or Islamic law) “guest edited” by the prophet himself. The cover promised “100 lashes if you don’t die of laughter!” Charlie Hebdo’s homepage was subsequently hacked and replaced with the single phrase “No god but Allah.” The office was attacked with a Molotov cocktail that destroyed all the property and equipment inside. (Following that, the magazine published a Muslim man kissing a cartoonist.)
Not all the controversies have centered around depictions of men. In 2010, Charlie Hebdo supported France’s controversial law banning women from wearing burqas in public with the headline “Yes to wearing the burqa … on the inside!”—the intended meaning of which is pretty self-explanatory from the image.
The paper has also mocked the pope on multiple occasions, but perhaps most famous is the 2010 image of Pope Benedict XVI holding a condom above his head saying “This is my body” (a line from the liturgy of the Eucharist that, according to the New Testament, was uttered by Jesus at the Last Supper). This was in response to an excerpt from the book-length interview Light of the World in which the pope says some confusing things about when it is OK to wear a condom. Many considered it to be a reversal for the church to allow condom use to prevent the spread of HIV. The pope said contraception can be “a first step in a movement toward a different way, a more human way, of living sexuality.”
Read more of Slate’s coverage of the Charlie Hebdo attack.
Miriam Krule is a Slate assistant editor. She writes about religion and culture and edits the photography blog Behold.
Monday, 24 November 2014
Tim Clark on MH 370
Full transcript: Emirates chief Sir Tim Clark on MH17 and MH370
- Date
"I do not believe that the information held by some is on the table": Sir Tim Clark. Photo: Nic Walker
- World's biggest mystery is in Martin Dolan's sights
- Sir Tim Clark believes information is being concealed
- Emirates head presses for change to prevent further tragedy
The full transcript of German aviation journalist Andreas Spaeth's interview with Emirates chief Sir Tim Clark.
It's many months later and we know nothing about MH370, having disappeared on March 8, 2014. What can be done?
TIM CLARK: Malaysia Airlines 370 remains one of the great aviation mysteries. Personally I have the concern that we will treat it like that and move on, and it will go onto National Geographic as one of aviation's great mysteries. We mustn't allow this to happen. This aeroplane has disappeared without trace. The public and the industry are questioning the lack of information and the cold hard logic of the disappearance of this and the factors that led to its disappearance. The tracking of the aircraft, its routing, its altitude oscillations, these were all measurable and explainable in my view. But we seem to have allowed it to go into this black hole of 'it could be one of aviation's great mysteries'. It can't be left like that, never. We must know what caused that aeroplane to disappear.
What do you think happened?
CLARK: My own view is that probably control was taken of that aeroplane, the events that happened during the course of its tracked flight will be anybody's guess of who did what and when. I think we need to know who was on this aeroplane in the detail that obviously some people do know, we need to know what was in the hold of the aeroplane, in the detail we need to know, in a transparent manner. And we need to continue to press all those stake holders, that were and are involved in the analysis, in the assessment of what happened, for more information. Because heading an airline that operates the largest number of 777s in the world, I have a responsibility of knowing exactly what went on. I do not subscribe to the view that the aircraft, which is one of the most advanced in the world, has the most advanced avionic and communication platforms, needs to be improved so that we can introduce some kind of additional tracking system for an aeroplane that should never have been allowed to enter into a non-trackable situation.
What do you mean by that?
CLARK: The transponders are under the control of the flight deck. These are tracking devices, aircraft identifiers, that work in the secondary radar regime. If you turn off that transponder in a secondary radar regime, it causes a disappearance of that particular aeroplane from the radar screen. That should never be allowed to happen. All secondary and primary radar should be the same. Irrespective of when the pilot decides to disable the transponder, the aircraft should be able to be tracked. So the notion by the Malaysians that the disappearance from the secondary radar and then the ability of the military to use primary radar to track the aeroplane and identify it as 'friendly' – I don't know how they did that - is something we need to look at very carefully.
What about other ways of monitoring?
CLARK: The other means of constantly monitoring the process of the track of an aircraft is the Aircraft Communication and Reporting System, ACARS. That is designed primarily for the companies to monitor what the aeroplanes are doing, we use it for a number of things, but primarily to monitor the aircraft systems and engine performance. So we track from the ground, as we do at Emirates, every single aircraft and every component of the aircraft and engine of the aircraft at any point of the planet, and very often we are able to track faults in the systems before the pilots do. It's that good and it's that real time.
How was it possible to disable that?
CLARK: Disabling it is no simple thing, and our pilots are not trained to disable ACARS. There are ways to enter the system through the multiple menu levels to get through and disable, but to completely disable also requires you to go down below the main deck into the avionics bay. That requires you to leave the flight deck and go down through a trap door in the floor to do that. But somehow this thing was disabled, so much so that the ground tracking capability was eliminated.
What should be the consequence?
CLARK: We must find systems to allow ACARS to continue uninterrupted, irrespective of who is controlling the aircraft. So that is not something somebody can do. If you have that, with the satellite constellations that we have today even in the Southern Ocean, we still have the capability of monitoring. So you don't have to introduce additional tracking systems. We are told we are saying that because we don't want to spend money. I have no problem spending and Emirates is one of the first to step out and ensure that safety is never compromised. But I have to be persuaded that adding additional tracking systems on top of what we already have is really worthwhile.
So what should be done then?
My recommendation to the aircraft manufacturer group is that they find a way to make disabling of the ACARS system impossible by the flight deck. And the transponder as well - I'm still struggling to find why a pilot should be able to put the transponder into standby or off. In my view, that should not be an option. Thirdly, the air traffic control systems should not have a situation where a non-transponder aircraft without its squawk identifier should not be allowed to turn off and still not be able to track it. This is absolute stuff of nonsense. Radar is radar, it will pick up metal objects flying at the speed of the size of a 777 without any difficulty. Who took the decision to say: 'If a transponder is off, we can't track it in a secondary radar regime'? Which apparently most air traffic control systems are in. We must look at that as well. This aircraft in my opinion was under control, probably until the very end.
But why would they fly down five hours straight towards Antarctica?
If they did! I am saying that every single element of the 'facts' of this particular incident must be challenged and examined in full transparency, exhausted to the point that there is no other way that we can think of this other than a complete mystery. We are nowhere near that, there is plenty of information out there, which we need to be far more forthright, transparent and candid about. All the entities involved like the NTSB, the Malaysians, the Australians, Boeing itself, whatever. They all know that people like me, and I hope the Malaysians are in this boat, too, will not allow this to go into that box of oblivion. Every single second of that flight needs to be examined. From the point on its heading in a north-easterly direction where it 'disappeared' off the screen and made a conscious left turn to go almost due West in controlled flight. There were apparently some oscillations in altitude from 41.000 to 27.000 feet, then the notion that it turned between existing waypoints on a north-easterly, then a north-westerly, then a south-westerly heading, where it theoretically then ended up in the Southern Ocean. For which they couldn't find a trace in 1.7 million square miles of search, nothing, they say.
So you nurture doubts that it actually happened as is said?
When you press questions on this, I sense a degree of belligerence, the more belligerent people become, the more worried I become. They have used AF447 as an example, where it was two years to track the aircraft, but very shortly after the incident they found the fin, floating. So we knew that the aircraft had gone in. And yes, there were all sorts of oceanographic issues with the currents and it took us two years to find. But in this case, there wasn't a seat cushion, and our experience tells us that in water incidents, where the aircraft has gone down, there is always something. We have not seen a single thing that suggests categorically that this aircraft is where they say it is, nothing. Apart from this 'handshake', which calls my electronic engineers to start thinking 'what is all this about?'.
What is their conclusion?
CLARK: They say, even though they disabled satellite communication and the ACARS, it is actually not disabled, it is still powered up and sends out weak signals that hunt, like you would do with a mobile phone. And therefore it is traceable. Well, I question this 'handshake' as well. In the Southern Ocean, with a very weak signal, which is intermittent, and they are a multitude of other aircraft in the same area, I'm not sure about that. Those are the things that need to be challenged. First of all let's establish what actually happened. If the industry then believes there is a case to put extra tracking devices on board, we can look at it. But don't walk down a blind alley. Many people, including at IATA, are going down this path. I don't agree with it.
At which point in the presumed flight path do your doubts start?
CLARK: There hasn't been one overwater incident in the history of civil aviation, apart form Amelia Earhart in 1939, that has not been at least five or ten percent trackable. This has disappeared. So for me that raises a degree of suspicion, and I'm totally dissatisfied with what is been coming out of all of this.
Who can change that?
CLARK: I'm not in a position to do it, I'm essentially an airline manager. But I will continue to ask the questions and will make a nuisance of myself, when others would like to bury it, and we have an obligation to the passengers and crew of MH 370 and their families, whose deep distress you see every day. We have an obligation not to brush this under the carpet, but to sort it out and do better than we have done.
So the search efforts undertaken so far were not good enough?
CLARK: They will start the search now again in the Southern Ocean, but look at what they had there: The Russians, the Chinese, the British, the Australians, the Malaysians. They had so many aircraft there that at one point, they had to bring in a separate aircraft to control their movements, so they didn't bump into each other. And still, nothing. Now, months later, they are gonna start again, but they couldn't find anything with all these entities before. This is very strange.
What is your gut feeling, will we at some point know more about what actually happened?
I think we will know more if there is full transparency of everything that everybody knows. I do not believe that the information held by some is on the table. Who actually disabled ACARS, who knew how to do it? If you eliminate the pilot on a suicide mission, I'm sure you could have put the aircraft in the South China Sea, rather than fly it for seven hours. So if he was on a suicide mission, he would have done it then. Who then took control of the aircraft? Who then knew how to disable ACARS and turn the transponder off? That is a huge challenge.
Can you understand that there is still so much disbelief everywhere how this could have ever happened in this time and age?
CLARK: Therein lies this huge question mark in my mind. I know this did not have to happen, there is technology to track these aircraft and everybody will say that, Boeing or Airbus. That is where the conundrum is of mystery, that is where we must be more forthright and candid as to what went on, it is not good enough for the Malaysian military to say: "On a prime radar we identified it as 'friendly'".
The role of the Malaysian military appears to be particularly murky.
CLARK: This is a very busy part of Southeast Asia, the notion that we should not be able to identify if it is friend or foe, or we can on primary radar and do nothing about it, is bizarre. What would have happened if the aircraft would have turned back to fly into the Petronas Towers in Kuala Lumpur? But we identified it as "friendly"? Friendly with intent, or friendly without intent? But what was done? These are the questions that need to be asked of the people and the entities that were involved in all of this. Full transparency of that will help us to find out what went on.
On MH17
There are million-dollar rewards offered now by interested parties to help solve both cases, MH 370 and also MH 17. Will that help?
MH 17's cause is completely different, but an equally tragic incident which the industry needed to respond to. The notion of a reward is something new to us. There is criminal culpability in what happened in my view. The aircraft was clearly taken down by ordnance, and even if people are shy to say it – it was taken down by a missile. They talk about multiple penetration of high velocity – well hello, that's not likely to be a goose, is it? So this aircraft was shot down. Others are saying it was by accident, I don't believe that. I believe the aircraft was taken down in the full knowledge of what it was.
Why, what purpose would that serve for anybody?
CLARK: Eventually, those responsible for it will be asked that. Hopefully in the courts. I can't speak for them. All I do know is the complexity of the equipment that was used: The need for the equipment to track what they were actually going to take down. Identify it and set it up to feed the information from the control vehicle into the missile, feed the data, so that the missile could log on. This wasn't a heat-seeking missile. It was a missile that can go up to 79,000 feet. So there was a risk up to 79,000 feet, we don't fly up there, it could have almost taken a satellite down. We need to ask those questions and we need to have answers. Clearly there are players like the Dutch who say this was a criminal action and should be treated accordingly under the normal courts of international justice. It was a criminal act, I would call it premeditated mass murder. I hope that in time those responsible will be brought to book.
Why were this and other aircraft flying this route at all?
CLARK: Concerning the route and altitude it was flying, back in July, I was distinctly troubled by what had happened on top of Malaysia flight 370. We could have done better as an industry in bringing together the information that was allowed to float around among us. I was very pleased that my public criticism of IATA and ICAO was picked up and a security conference set up for February, which is definitely a step in the right direction. I have spoken to many CEOs in my peer group, all competitors, who agree that we need to improve what we do.
What would that be?
CLARK: It is all very well to say that air space is controlled by the country that we fly over and that it is up to them what to do. But when a country is split in half by a civil war, things change altogether. As an airline group we should have said 'Look, are we sure that the Ukrainian government has control of the air space in which we fly over, are we sure that we cannot be attacked?'. Even though they say it's clear above a certain flight level. And if that is the case, then we must be absolutely sure that we do not put our passengers, crew and aircraft at risk.
Did Emirates avoid eastern Ukrainian air space before MH 17 and if so, why was that?
CLARK: Very few, if any, of our flights went through. We were serving Kiev, which we stopped almost immediately. And the routing to Kiev was a southerly routing over the Black Sea and then going north into Kiev. So we avoided this airspace.
Did you as Emirates have any information of potential danger at the time of MH 17?
CLARK: No, I had no idea, personally, that there was this kind of ordnance being moved into the east of the country. And had I known that, I would have most definitely said that I weren't happy about that. And we know that some did know and I'm not blaming them, it is very difficult. The sensitivities of passing on information supply by the intelligence apparatuses in various countries is, by nature, secret.
How can that be overcome?
CLARK: What I am trying to crack is that ability for the airline community to take this information, irrespective of source, how secret it may be, and not question where it came from. But rather say, 'this is likely to be the case, please help us so we can make that decisions'. And I think out of this, working groups in IATA and ICAO will come along. The world was truly and utterly shocked by this, all governments were deeply affected by it. It was a game changer in my view, it had to be dealt with on that basis. They all needed to do better.
Because the world doesn't get more peaceful at the moment.
CLARK: Unfortunately, the world today is full of conflict zones. We as an airline community have sometimes little choice but to travel through these conflict zones, or completely avoid them, just not fly. Now we stopped flying to Erbil, to Damascus, to Tripoli, just recently to Sana'a, we had a question mark over Peshawar in Pakistan. These are things we deal with as management all the time. The more information I get, the easier it makes the job for me. We took the decision not to fly over Iraq after all this and people say: 'Did you know something?'. I didn't know anything, it was in my view on the balance of risk.
Why did the airlines themselves had to decide if and where to fly, or not at all?
CLARK: In fairness, airlines that have a supervisory authority like the FAA in the US or our Department of Civil Aviation in the UAE, they tell us where to fly or not to fly. It's not all about the airlines taking their decisions, most of the time there is a dialogue between the regulator and everybody else. But sometimes, the airlines know more than the regulators. If the regulators of other countries had access to what that particular regulator knows about that particular bit of air space, and we share it in a fairly sanitised manner, so they didn't disclose, I'm sure we'll be far better off.
If you were at the helm of Malaysia Airlines today, what would you do?
CLARK: Very difficult one, none of us has been in this business before of having to deal with two tragedies within a few months of each other. Malaysia Airlines carries the brand of Malaysia. It is their ambassador for trade, very difficult to deal with the stigma. A fresh look at what they do, a revisiting of their business model, possibly a rebranding.
Can this brand survive at all?
CLARK: In the end we'll move on, the airline has to continue to trade. For it to disappear because it had these two frightful incidents, I think all of us in the industry would say this shouldn't be allowed to happen. We need to find a way to help these guys sort out their problems. With that kind of brand damage, that occurred to them, it's extraordinary difficult. In the end, I'm sure they are going through a major re-think, soul searching of what they have to do, they have to keep the airline going, it's so important for what they are. They find a way to do it and people will return to it. So time will tell, but it's not easy. They will try to rebrand it, not just the title, but its whole ethos and DNA, they'll gonna have to try persuade the public that these were accidents beyond their control, and move on from that, that they were so unlucky to be subjected to that.
The cruise ship industry felt a big negative impact after the accident of the "Costa Concordia" in 2012. Aviation did not suffer the same way after these two extraordinary accidents this year. Why is it more resilient?
CLARK: Aviation plays a more critical role in what it does than perhaps the cruise industry. The cruise industry is there purely for leisure, and it's a great industry. But it does not glue the planet. Air travel does, the aviation industry is the physical glue of what goes on. Without it, the world would come to a rapid halt, as we've seen during the volcanic ash situation.
Monday, 17 November 2014
Logging in Sarawak post Taib
Published: Monday November 17, 2014 MYT 4:24:00 PM
Updated: Monday November 17, 2014 MYT 4:53:06 PM
BY YU JI

Adenan gestures while making a point in his speech on illegal logging
KUCHING: At a rare gathering of Sarawak’s biggest timber tycoons, Chief Minister Tan Sri Adenan Satem surprised the audience by labelling the industry "corrupt."
And he warned the logging bosses that he will “put the fear of God into people who are dishonest”.
Adenan, who on Monday brought together bosses of the state’s “big six” logging firms to sign “integrity pledges”, took the opportunity to issue his sternest warning yet on illegal logging.
He named the big six as KTS, Rimbunan Hijau, Samling, Shin Yang, Ta Ann and WTK and told them "don't mess with me”.
To the officers enforcing the state's logging laws, Adenan warned that he will not tolerate officers “with eyes but blind, with ears but deaf and with mouths but dumb”.
He described the present state of corruption as “very bad, a reflection of what enforcement officers have not been doing”.
“Some, of course not all, pretend they don’t know. The reason is very simple; either they are stupid, cowards or corrupt,” Adenan said to a stunned audience, comprising state Cabinet members, civil servants and some of Sarawak’s richest individuals.
“I’ll get you with the assistance of the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Agency (MACC). If we let these things go on we’ll lose our forests.
"Some (enforcers) have said they are afraid of gangsters, they are afraid of receiving bullets in the mail, well, you tell them, ‘Adenan told you to enforce the law’. No more excuses not to do anything.”
Adenan said Sarawakians must not tolerate corruption anymore because millions had been lost revenue and the state gained a bad reputation internationally because of “this robbery which is carried out in broad daylight.”
He told the logging firms to “watch out and lecture your contractors, sub-contractors, camp managers, suppliers, etc."
"Tell them to be careful, insist they must pledge integrity," he said.
Adenan added he was sure the MACC would be making more arrests.
“I mean what I say. I do not ‘cakap sahaja’ (talk only), no action... The state of corruption is very bad. Very bad. I cannot tolerate it anymore.”
Adenan said he would "go after" civil servants and require them to attend talks by the MACC and to get his Cabinet to sign integrity pledges.
He said the state government would also gazette more forests as national parks.
"I will create more national parks, more than the United Nations requirement of 10% (of the state’s land mass).”
The signing of the integrity pledges by the logging firms was held at the Sarawak Legislative Assembly complex here.
This present sitting is in the closing stages and the issue of illegal logging has been hotly
debated.
Criticisms by Violet Yong (DAP-Pending) against Second Resource Planning and Environment Minister Datuk Amar Awang Tengah Ali Hasan for failing to curb illegal logging has landed her in trouble.
A motion to refer Yong to the privileges committee was passed, due to her comments last Friday when she said: “If I were the minister, I would have resigned and felt ashamed of myself and not know where to hide my face. And if I were the minister in charge of this portfolio in Japan,
I would have killed myself.”
The motion against Yong was proposed by Tengah himself, who said he felt insulted, and seconded by Welfare, Women and Family Development Minister Datuk Fatimah Abdullah, after Yong refused to retract her statement in the House when given the opportunity.
Yong told reporters later that she was unsatisfied with Tengah’s past answers on illegal logging in Sarawak, which had necessitated Adenan to own up to failures and step up enforcement.
State Opposition leader Chong Chieng Jen (DAP-Kota Sentosa) defended Yong, saying Tengah’s past assurance of “only 0.01%” of lost revenue due to illegal logging contrasted against Adenan’s statements, which showed the former had indeed failed in his duties to protect the forest.
Chong also criticised Tengah for not following the chief minister's move to sign the integrity pledge.
You're corrupt, Adenan Satem tells Sarawak's timber tycoons
BY YU JI
Adenan gestures while making a point in his speech on illegal logging
KUCHING: At a rare gathering of Sarawak’s biggest timber tycoons, Chief Minister Tan Sri Adenan Satem surprised the audience by labelling the industry "corrupt."
And he warned the logging bosses that he will “put the fear of God into people who are dishonest”.
Adenan, who on Monday brought together bosses of the state’s “big six” logging firms to sign “integrity pledges”, took the opportunity to issue his sternest warning yet on illegal logging.
He named the big six as KTS, Rimbunan Hijau, Samling, Shin Yang, Ta Ann and WTK and told them "don't mess with me”.
To the officers enforcing the state's logging laws, Adenan warned that he will not tolerate officers “with eyes but blind, with ears but deaf and with mouths but dumb”.
He described the present state of corruption as “very bad, a reflection of what enforcement officers have not been doing”.
“Some, of course not all, pretend they don’t know. The reason is very simple; either they are stupid, cowards or corrupt,” Adenan said to a stunned audience, comprising state Cabinet members, civil servants and some of Sarawak’s richest individuals.
“I’ll get you with the assistance of the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Agency (MACC). If we let these things go on we’ll lose our forests.
"Some (enforcers) have said they are afraid of gangsters, they are afraid of receiving bullets in the mail, well, you tell them, ‘Adenan told you to enforce the law’. No more excuses not to do anything.”
Adenan said Sarawakians must not tolerate corruption anymore because millions had been lost revenue and the state gained a bad reputation internationally because of “this robbery which is carried out in broad daylight.”
He told the logging firms to “watch out and lecture your contractors, sub-contractors, camp managers, suppliers, etc."
"Tell them to be careful, insist they must pledge integrity," he said.
Adenan added he was sure the MACC would be making more arrests.
“I mean what I say. I do not ‘cakap sahaja’ (talk only), no action... The state of corruption is very bad. Very bad. I cannot tolerate it anymore.”
Adenan said he would "go after" civil servants and require them to attend talks by the MACC and to get his Cabinet to sign integrity pledges.
He said the state government would also gazette more forests as national parks.
"I will create more national parks, more than the United Nations requirement of 10% (of the state’s land mass).”
The signing of the integrity pledges by the logging firms was held at the Sarawak Legislative Assembly complex here.
This present sitting is in the closing stages and the issue of illegal logging has been hotly
debated.
Criticisms by Violet Yong (DAP-Pending) against Second Resource Planning and Environment Minister Datuk Amar Awang Tengah Ali Hasan for failing to curb illegal logging has landed her in trouble.
A motion to refer Yong to the privileges committee was passed, due to her comments last Friday when she said: “If I were the minister, I would have resigned and felt ashamed of myself and not know where to hide my face. And if I were the minister in charge of this portfolio in Japan,
I would have killed myself.”
The motion against Yong was proposed by Tengah himself, who said he felt insulted, and seconded by Welfare, Women and Family Development Minister Datuk Fatimah Abdullah, after Yong refused to retract her statement in the House when given the opportunity.
Yong told reporters later that she was unsatisfied with Tengah’s past answers on illegal logging in Sarawak, which had necessitated Adenan to own up to failures and step up enforcement.
State Opposition leader Chong Chieng Jen (DAP-Kota Sentosa) defended Yong, saying Tengah’s past assurance of “only 0.01%” of lost revenue due to illegal logging contrasted against Adenan’s statements, which showed the former had indeed failed in his duties to protect the forest.
Chong also criticised Tengah for not following the chief minister's move to sign the integrity pledge.
Wednesday, 5 November 2014
Regional Stereotypes
Chinese American Kaiser Kuo (郭怡广) is former rock god and presently communications director of Baidu. What list members may not know is that Kaiser is particularly fond of the Quora platform (a sort of social QA site) and frequently posts answers on China-related questions. Questions usually raised by Western Quora users.
One recent Quora question was: “What are the TL;DRs (or stereotypes) of the various provinces of China?”. Kaiser responded with a poem he had previously composed:
In Dongbei, whence the Manchus came, the men do like their liquor.
While effusive with their friendship, with their enmity they’re quicker
Though they’re honest and straightforward, at the slightest provocation
They’ll show why they’ve been slandered as the Klingons of this nation.
The leggy Dongbei ladies for their beauty are renowned,
(I attest that in my travels, few more fetching have I found.)
But they suffer from one drawback, and it’s very sad to tell—
When they open up their mouths to speak, they break that magic spell.
The stalwart Shandong people grow as hearty as their scallions
On their noodle-heavy diet they’ve been bred as strong as stallions.
They’re known for dogged loyalty; they’re known as trusty folks,
But a bit slow on the uptake—thus, the butt of many jokes.
In Hunan and in Hubei in the country’s center-south
They say the people there can really run it at the mouth
In Hubei in particular, the saying is often heard
That a single Hubei codger can drown out a nine-head bird.
The Hunanese, in temperament, are piquant as their dishes,
Like duo jiao yu tou—capsicum with slow-braised heads of fishes.
Add to this mix the province’s infernal summer heat,
And you see why Hunan’s Xiang Jun had the Taiping rebels beat.
The teahouses of Chengdu represent the Sichuan Way:
The women toil in earnest while the men drink tea and play.
The Chuan hou plays at mahjong as the Chuan mei cleans and mends,
And like the Sichuan peppers do, she burns it at both ends.
The Pearl River Delta in the southlands of Guangzhou
Is home to China’s most industrious people, as you know:
They’re scrappy and they’re gritty and they’re free of all pretension,
And they’ll make a meal of any living beast you’d care to mention.
They say that Henan people are a sly and cunning lot.
But my ancestors are from there—proving some, at least, are not.
My co-provincials countrywide are blamed for every ill,
While provinces that suck as bad get let off easy still.
The Shanghainese are philistines, and this they’ll gladly own:
Commercial instincts permeate them to the very bone.
Their pride in Shanghai’s petit bourgeois ethos is immense
But what they lack in culture, they make up in common sense.
As you might well have expected, I have saved the best for last,
For my love for Beijing’s people is immovably steadfast.
From their gargling r-drenched accent to their dry sardonic wit,
The denizens of Jing Town are the dope, the bomb, the shit.
Beijingers love to gab, and though they’re lazy and they’re slow,
There’s nothing about politics that they aren’t apt to know.
They may complain a lot about the traffic and the air
But scratch beneath the cynicism and you’ll find they care.
So be grateful that you live here, and be clear on what it means.
Be grateful you don’t live among Klingons, or philistines.
Be grateful for the legacy of Yuan and Ming and Qing—
And most of all be grateful for the people of Beijing.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)










